Insights
Should a fence company sell fence materials to DIY customers?
When selling fence materials to DIY customers makes sense, how to follow up with install offers and how to track both lead types.
- Author
- Gorilla Works Marketing
- Published
- Reading time
- 7 min read
A fence company can sell materials to DIY customers if it treats those calls as a top-of-funnel channel, not a distraction. Stock what you install, be clear about what DIY support you will not provide, and mail an install offer card later. Track materials leads and install leads separately.
Selling fence materials looks like extra work. It can be the first conversation that turns into an install later.
A homeowner who calls about panels, posts or gates is already thinking about a fence. Some of them will build it themselves. Some will start the project, get stuck and want a crew. If you treat every materials call as a waste of time, you lose both the sale in front of you and the install that might follow. If you treat it as a lead, you can help the honest DIY buyer and stay first in line when they want the job done for them.
This guide shows when materials sales make sense, what to tell DIY buyers up front, how a follow-up card turns a materials ticket into an install conversation, how to stay out of a price fight with big-box aisles, and how to track both kinds of leads.
Want a follow-up card that invites a materials buyer back for a full install? Book a free demo.
The short version
- Sell materials only if you stock what you install and can answer those calls without stalling estimate work.
- Tell DIY buyers up front what you will and will not help with on a self-install.
- Mail an install offer card later to people who bought materials or called about them.
- Compete on advice, local proof and a clean install path, not on matching a store shelf.
- Track materials leads and install leads as two different sources.
In this guide
- Why would a fence company sell materials?
- What should you tell DIY buyers up front?
- How do you turn materials buyers into install jobs?
- How do you avoid competing only on price with big-box stores?
- How do you track materials vs install leads?
Why would a fence company sell materials?
A fence company would sell materials to meet homeowners who are already planning a fence, to move stock you use on your own jobs, and to open a later install conversation with people who started out wanting to build it themselves. The materials ticket is not the whole point. The relationship is.
Materials sales fit when:
- You already stock the panels, posts, gates and hardware you install
- Someone in the shop can answer materials calls without ignoring estimate calls
- You can explain, in plain words, what a DIY buyer is taking on
- You will follow up later with an install offer, not hope they remember you
They are a poor fit when materials questions bury your estimate calendar, or when you would have to stock products you never install.
What should you tell DIY buyers up front?
You should tell DIY buyers what you stock, what a self-install involves, and what help you will not provide after they leave with the materials. Clarity protects both of you. A buyer who hears the limits on day one is less likely to call you mid-project expecting free troubleshooting, and more likely to respect an install offer later.
Spell out, before you take their money:
- Which materials you sell, and that they match what you install
- That a DIY project is their responsibility once the materials leave your yard
- What you will not do, such as layout help on site, tool loans or mid-build rescue calls
- How to book an install estimate instead, if they would rather have your crew do the work
Keep the tone helpful, not dismissive. The goal is a clean yes or no: they buy materials with their eyes open, or they book an estimate. For homeowners who want a number first, an online fence quote can point them toward an install conversation without turning the counter into a debate.
How do you turn materials buyers into install jobs?
You turn materials buyers into install jobs by following up after the sale with a custom card that offers a full install, not by pressuring them at the counter. Let them buy what they came for. Then mail a reminder that your crew installs the same products they just looked at.
You already have that buyer's address and phone if they purchased from you or requested a materials quote. Send a short install offer card with a photo of a finished fence built from the same kind of material, a clear next step and a number that rings your office. Custom direct mail is built for that kind of follow-up. Gorilla Works Marketing builds lists with AI from 200+ data variables plus statistical modeling, then designs, prints, mails and tracks each drop. For buyers already in your records you supply the name and address. For homes around a finished install, you don't need to bring a list.
People read mail. In the USPS Household Mail Survey, household members read 51% of advertising mail pieces and set aside another 10% to read later.
What the follow-up card should do:
- Thank them for the materials visit or order
- Show a finished fence in the same material
- Offer an install estimate, with one way to respond
- Stay friendly if they still want to build it themselves
See what a fence company should put on a postcard and learn more about custom direct mail.
How do you avoid competing only on price with big-box stores?
You avoid competing only on price by selling the materials you install well, explaining the project honestly and making the install path easy, instead of trying to beat a store aisle. A big-box shelf can show a panel. It cannot show your last street of finished fences.
Ways to stay out of a shelf fight:
- Stock what your crews actually install, so advice and product match
- Show photos of local jobs built with those materials
- Offer a clear install estimate to anyone who would rather not build it
- Leave other companies' names out of your ads
Do not use marketing to pick a fight with a retailer. Sell your own work. For the broader local-versus-store question, read how a local fence company can compete with big-box store installers.
How do you track materials vs install leads?
Track materials leads and install leads separately so a busy counter does not hide a weak install pipeline, or the reverse. A materials call that later books an install should show both steps: first contact as materials, won job as install. If you mix them in one bucket, you cannot tell whether the counter is paying off.
What to log:
- First contact type: materials question or install estimate
- Whether they bought materials
- Whether you mailed an install offer card
- Whether they later booked an install estimate
- Whether the install was signed
Give the follow-up card its own phone number or QR code so those replies do not get mixed with neighbor mail or website forms. Read how to track direct mail campaigns, and see how causal analytics separates real lift from noise.
DIY materials checklist
- ✅ Stock only what you install
- ✅ Limits stated before the materials leave your yard
- ✅ Install path offered to anyone who would rather not DIY
- ✅ Follow-up card mailed after a materials call or purchase
- ✅ No retailer jabs in your ads or cards
- ✅ Two lead types tracked from first contact to signed work
FAQ
Will DIY buyers waste my time?
Some will, if you let every materials question turn into a long consult. Qualify fast: what they need, whether you stock it, and whether they want materials only or an install estimate. A short, honest answer protects your day.
Should materials be cheaper than an installed fence?
Set your own materials pricing and your own install pricing. Do not try to win DIY buyers by matching a store shelf in your marketing. This guide does not name figures.
Do I need a mailing list?
Materials callers and buyers become contacts you already have, and those are the people who get the install offer card. For postcards to homes around a finished install, you don't need a mailing list. Read do I need a mailing list to send direct mail?
Treat the counter as a lead source
A fence company can sell materials to DIY customers when it tells the truth up front, follows up with an install offer card and tracks materials leads apart from install leads. See direct mail for fence companies and book a free demo.
Explore more practical marketing guidance: Should a fence company send thank-you cards after every job?; How do temporary fence companies get more rental customers?; How do farm and ranch fence contractors find customers?; and How do fence companies ask customers for referrals?.
