Gorilla Works Marketing

Insights

Is email or direct mail better for fence companies?

A fence-company comparison of email and direct mail: consent, neighbor reach, how to use both and how to track each.

Author
Gorilla Works Marketing
Published
Reading time
8 min read

Email is better for fence companies when you already have permission to message past customers. Direct mail is better when you need to reach the homes around a finished fence that never opted in. We recommend both: email for the opted-in customer list, custom direct mail for the neighborhood, and tracking for each.

Email works for fence companies that already have permission to write. It just can't reach the neighbor who never signed up.

That's the split that matters. A past customer who checked a box, hired you and gave you an address for updates can get a useful email about gates, repairs or stain. The household next to your last job never joined that list. A custom postcard can still land in their mailbox and show them the fence they already drive past.

This guide compares email and direct mail on consent, reach, staying power and tracking, then shows when to use each one and how they work together with the same job photo.

Want postcards that reach the homes around a finished fence, whether or not they opted in? Book a free demo.

The short version

  • Use email only with people who gave you permission to write them.
  • Use custom direct mail for the homes around a finished fence that never opted in.
  • Email is fast to send and easy to ignore.
  • A postcard sits on the counter until someone throws it away.
  • The same job photo should appear in both, with separate tracking.
  • We recommend running both and judging them by booked jobs.

In this guide

  1. How does email work for fence companies?
  2. How does direct mail work for fence companies?
  3. Email vs direct mail: how do they compare?
  4. When should a fence company use email?
  5. When should a fence company use direct mail?
  6. How do they work together with the same job photo?
  7. How do you track both?

How does email work for fence companies?

Email works for fence companies when a past customer has given you permission to write them, and you send a short, useful message about work they might want next. Consent is required. Do not buy a list of homeowner emails. Use email for people who already hired you and asked to hear from you.

What email does well for fence companies:

  • Reaches past customers who already know your name
  • Goes out quickly once you have the list and the message
  • Can carry a photo of their fence or a similar job
  • Uses time you already spend writing, if you have permission

Where email comes up short:

  • It only reaches people who opted in
  • It is easy to skip, filter or never open
  • It cannot introduce you to the neighbor who never joined your list

Keep the message useful: a maintenance reminder, a gate offer or a photo of completed work. Do not turn every note into a hard sell.

How does direct mail work for fence companies?

Direct mail works for fence companies by putting a printed card in the mailbox of homes around a fence you just built that never opted in. Gorilla Works Marketing builds the list with AI from 200+ data variables plus statistical modeling, then designs, prints, mails and tracks each drop. You don't need your own list.

People read it. In the USPS Household Mail Survey, household members read 51% of advertising mail pieces and set aside another 10% to read later. Households also read 64% of advertising mail from businesses they already use, compared with 36% from businesses they don't, which is why a card to a past customer still earns attention.

What direct mail does well for fence companies:

  • Reaches homes that never joined an email list
  • Shows a fence the neighbors can walk outside and see
  • Stays in the home until someone throws it away
  • Tracks calls and scans per drop with unique numbers and QR codes

Where direct mail asks more of you:

  • It takes planning and print time before it lands
  • Changes mean a new print run

Learn more about custom direct mail, whether direct mail works for fence companies and how fence companies market to neighbors after a job.

Email vs direct mail: how do they compare?

Email and direct mail compare differently on consent, reach, speed and staying power. Email wins when you already have permission and want to write past customers quickly. Custom direct mail wins when you need to reach specific homes that never opted in. Both can be tracked when each message or drop has its own link, number or code.

Consent

  • Email: required. Write only people who opted in.
  • Direct mail: you choose addresses, such as the homes around a finished fence

Reach

  • Email: your opted-in list, which is usually past customers
  • Direct mail: any homes you choose, including neighbors who never signed up

Speed

  • Email: can go out as soon as you write it
  • Direct mail: needs time to design, print and deliver

Staying power

  • Email: easy to skip or delete
  • Direct mail: sits on the counter or the fridge until someone tosses it

Tracking

  • Email: unique links per message
  • Direct mail: unique phone numbers and QR codes per drop

Best fence use

  • Email: updates and offers to past customers who asked to hear from you
  • Direct mail: the neighbors of each finished fence, and past customers who should get a card as well

When should a fence company use email?

Use email when you already have permission to write past customers and you have something useful to say, such as a follow-up after their install, a gate offer or a stain reminder. It fits when you want to reach people who know you without printing a card, and when someone will answer replies and phone calls that come back.

Email fits when:

  • The person opted in or is a customer who asked for updates
  • You want to send a photo or a short reminder quickly
  • You will handle replies the same day

Skip email when you do not have consent. Do not buy a list of homeowner emails to fill the gap.

When should a fence company use direct mail?

Use direct mail when you want to reach specific homes, especially the neighbors of a fence you just built. Those households never joined your email list, and a card with the finished fence photo is how they learn who did the work.

Direct mail fits when:

  • You just finished a fence and want the whole street to see it
  • You want to reach homes that never opted in
  • You want a reminder that stays in the house longer than an email

Read is direct mail better than Facebook ads for home service businesses?

See is direct mail better than Facebook ads for fence companies?.

How do they work together with the same job photo?

They work together when the email and the postcard show the same finished fence and the same offer, so people recognize you in both places. Email the past customer who opted in. Mail the homes around the job. Give each message its own tracking so you can see which one booked the estimate.

How to run both on one job:

  1. Pick one finished fence photo.
  2. Email opted-in past customers if the photo and offer are useful to them.
  3. Mail a custom postcard to the homes around the job.
  4. Give the email its own link, and the card its own number or QR code.
  5. Compare booked estimates from each.

How do you track both?

Track both by giving each email and each mail drop its own link, number or QR code, then logging every reply, call, estimate and signed job by source. Judge them by booked estimates and signed jobs, not opens or scans. Before you blame the postcard or the email, send yourself both and see what happens.

What to log:

  • Channel and message or drop name
  • Replies, calls and scans
  • Estimates booked
  • Jobs signed

Read how to track direct mail campaigns, and see how causal analytics separates real lift from noise.

Email vs direct mail checklist

  • ✅ Permission in place before any email goes out
  • ✅ Neighbor homes reached with a postcard, not an unsolicited email
  • ✅ Same job photo across both when you run them together
  • ✅ Separate tracking for every message and every drop
  • ✅ No purchased homeowner email lists
  • ✅ Judged by signed jobs, not opens or scans

FAQ

Which is cheaper, email or direct mail?

Don't pick a channel by a headline rate. Track both, then compare them by booked estimates and signed jobs. For a custom direct mail plan, book a free demo.

Can I buy an email list of homeowners?

No. This guide does not advise buying homeowner email lists. Write people who opted in. If you need to reach homes that never signed up, use custom direct mail instead. You don't need to bring a mailing list for those cards.

Do I need a mailing list for postcards?

No. Gorilla Works builds the list of homes around your jobs. Read do I need a mailing list to send direct mail?

Write the people who asked, mail the street that didn't

Email is the better tool for opted-in past customers, and custom direct mail is the better tool for neighbors who never signed up. We recommend both, tracked separately and judged by signed jobs. See direct mail for fence companies and book a free demo.

Sources

  1. https://about.usps.com/what/performance/household-mail-survey/