Insights
What are the best direct mail options for fence companies?
Five direct mail options for fence companies compared by who they reach, how they track and when to use each, from custom mail to door hangers.
- Author
- Gorilla Works Marketing
- Published
- Reading time
- 8 min read
The best direct mail options for fence companies are the ones that reach homes near your finished fences and show you which cards booked jobs. A custom direct mail partner builds that list and tracks it. Local printers and EDDM route mail cover neighborhoods more broadly, and door hangers work on the street you just built on.
Every direct mail option can put a card in a mailbox. The real difference is whether you can see which card booked the job.
That gap matters more than the paper, the size or the design. A fence company that knows which street, which card and which offer brought in the estimate can mail that street again with confidence. A fence company that doesn't know is guessing with every drop.
This guide compares five direct mail options by what a fence company actually needs: homes around finished jobs, past customers and clear tracking.
Want to see which homes around your last fence would get a card? Book a free demo.
The short version
- Pick a direct mail option by who it reaches, how it tracks and how much of your time it takes.
- A custom direct mail partner builds the list around your jobs, designs the card and tracks results.
- A local printer works well when you already have a clean customer list.
- EDDM route mail covers whole routes without names or addresses.
- Door hangers fit the street you just built on.
- Online print-and-mail tools suit owners who want to do every step themselves.
In this guide
- How should a fence company compare direct mail options?
- Custom direct mail partner
- Addressed postcards from a local printer
- EDDM route mail
- Door hangers
- Online print-and-mail tools
- Which option should a fence company start with?
- How do you track any direct mail option?
How should a fence company compare direct mail options?
A fence company should compare direct mail options on three things: who the mail reaches, whether you can track calls and scans back to each drop, and how much of your own time each step takes. Fence jobs cluster by neighborhood, so we recommend starting with the option that puts a card in front of the right homes near your work.
Questions to ask before you pick one:
- Reach: does it go to chosen homes, a whole route or one street?
- List: do you need to bring your own mailing list?
- Design: who writes and designs the card?
- Tracking: does each drop get its own phone number or QR code?
- Your time: how many steps land on your desk?
Hold every option below up to those five questions.
1. Custom direct mail partner
Best for: fence companies that want cards sent to chosen homes around finished jobs and past customers, with tracking on every drop.
How it works: a custom direct mail partner plans the campaign, builds the list, designs the card, prints it, mails it and reports what happened. You don't need your own mailing list. Gorilla Works Marketing builds the list with AI from 200+ data variables, backed by statistical modeling, and connects mail results with your Google, Meta and SEO work.
Pros:
- Cards go to the homes you choose, such as the streets around a new fence.
- Each drop can carry its own tracking number and QR code.
- One team handles strategy, design, print and mail.
- Past customers and neighbors can get different cards.
Cons:
- You plan with a partner, so the first drop takes a conversation.
- It asks you to share job addresses so the list fits your work.
Ideal use: mailing the neighbors of each finished fence, reminding past customers about gates and repairs, and testing one offer against another with real tracking. See how custom direct mail works and direct mail for fence companies.
For how this compares with a print shop, read does direct mail work for fence companies?
2. Addressed postcards from a local printer
Best for: fence owners who already keep a clean list of past customers and want a printer they can visit.
How it works: you bring the list and the design, the printer prints and mails the cards. Some printers offer design help.
Pros:
- A local face and quick reprints.
- Good for mailing customers you already know.
Cons:
- You supply the list, the strategy and usually the tracking.
- Finding new homes near your jobs is up to you.
Ideal use: a thank-you or gate-check card to your own customer list.
3. EDDM route mail
Best for: covering every address on a mail carrier route around a neighborhood.
How it works: EDDM (Every Door Direct Mail) goes to every address on the routes you pick, without names or a mailing list.
Pros:
- No list needed.
- Broad coverage of a whole route.
Cons:
- Every home on the route gets the card, whether or not it fits your work.
- Route coverage makes it harder to match calls to specific streets.
Ideal use: a broad neighborhood drop when you want coverage more than precision. The full comparison is in should a fence company use EDDM or an addressed mailing list?
4. Door hangers
Best for: the street you just built on, delivered by hand while your crew is nearby.
How it works: your crew or a helper hangs a printed card on the doors around a finished job.
Pros:
- Lands within a day of the job, while the new fence is fresh.
- Easy to tie to one address: "We just built the fence at the corner."
Cons:
- It takes crew time and covers only the homes you can walk to.
- Local rules on door hangers vary, so check before you hang.
Ideal use: a same-week follow-up on one street. Read do door hangers work for fence companies?
5. Online print-and-mail tools
Best for: owners who want to upload a design and a list and press send themselves.
How it works: you sign up, upload a list, pick a template and schedule the mailing online.
Pros:
- Fast to start.
- You control every setting.
Cons:
- The list, the message and the tracking plan are all on you.
- Templates are built for every trade, so fence-specific strategy comes from you.
Ideal use: owners with time, a clean list and a clear plan who want to run each step alone.
Which direct mail option should a fence company start with?
Start with the option that matches your goal. To win more jobs near the fences you already built, use a custom direct mail partner so the list and the tracking are handled. To thank past customers, a local printer works. For one street this week, use door hangers. Mixing options is fine as long as each one has its own tracking.
A simple way to decide:
- Goal is new neighbors near your jobs: custom direct mail partner.
- Goal is past-customer repeat work: custom partner or local printer with your list.
- Goal is one street, right now: door hangers.
- Goal is broad route coverage: EDDM, kept short and tracked.
For the full neighbor plan, read how fence companies market to neighbors after a job.
How do you track any direct mail option?
Track any direct mail option by giving each drop its own phone number or QR code, then logging every call, scan, estimate and booked job against that drop. Without tracking, every option looks the same, because you can't tell which card did the work. With it, you know which street, card and offer to mail again.
What to log for each drop:
- Option used and date mailed
- Homes or route covered
- Calls, scans and form fills
- Estimates given and jobs booked
People do read this mail. In the USPS Household Mail Survey, household members read 51% of advertising mail pieces and set aside another 10% to read later. Tracking tells you which of those readers became customers.
Read how to track direct mail campaigns, and see how causal analytics separates real lift from noise.
Direct mail options checklist
- ✅ Reach fits the homes you want, around jobs or past customers
- ✅ List is built for you, or you already have a clean one
- ✅ Card shows a real fence you built nearby
- ✅ Tracking with a unique number or QR code per drop
- ✅ Time cost you can actually carry during busy weeks
- ✅ Follow-up plan for every call the mail brings in
FAQ
Is direct mail still worth it for fence companies?
Yes, when it reaches the right homes and you track it. Household members read 51% of advertising mail pieces, per USPS. See does direct mail work for fence companies?
How much does each option cost?
Costs depend on the list, the card and the quantity. For a quote that fits your area, book a free demo or see pricing.
Do I need a mailing list?
Not for a custom direct mail partner or EDDM. Read do I need a mailing list to send direct mail?
Can I combine options?
Yes. You can pair door hangers on one street with custom postcards to the wider neighborhood. Give each its own tracking number.
Choose the option that shows you what worked
The best direct mail option for a fence company reaches homes near your finished fences and proves which cards booked jobs. Start there, track every drop and mail the streets that call. See direct mail for fence companies and book a free demo.
Explore more practical marketing guidance: What are the best fence company marketing ideas?.
